Movements of the Multitude- Integral Community Seminar 2012

Written by 

"We feel we need to evolve the ‘we’ (that’s the title of the event). We’ve spent the past couple hundred years evolving the individual. Some of us have evolved to a place that the individual act has limits. There's a place you get to in your own development where the potency of people coming together has so much potential. You can feel within yourself mandala-crop-300x288that there is a limitation to being one. The seminar is an exploration of that potential. What is the potential when people come together to explore the mystery of the authentic".  -Stephan Martineau, Next Step Integral

That was a passage from an interview that Br. Juma did with Stephan before last years Integral Community Seminar, an event that Beams and Struts supported and that I attended. I wrote a series of posts from that seminar which you can read beginning here if you're interested (the rest can be found by putting 'community seminar' in the search function). Beams is supporting this years seminar too and I'll be going again, and it looks like I'll be joined by a couple of my Beams colleagues too, so we're all excited about that.

So this is just a short post to let folks who might be interested know that this event is happening. If you want to learn more about the seminar, my posts are probably a decent entry point, as is the description of the event on Next Step Integral's website.

I'm personally looking forward to the seminar for several 35_HARDT_NEGRI_-_multitude_m_screasons. First off, I get to drive from Vancouver to Colorado with Juma, and well, everyone loves a road trip!! But beyond that enjoyable detail I do think this work of developing and deepening our capacity to be together in collectives is crucial work going forward. To look at this from a socio-political angle, we're coming out of a highly individualized epoch (in the West at least), and the consumer capitalist ideology of our period has only served to deepen and strengthen our separation. We'll never move beyond our current neoliberal form of Empire if we don't intentionally cultivate our collective capacities together. The new power of collectives and collective action- of the multitude in motion- has shown its power in recent world shifting events, from Egypt to Greece to the Pirate Party in Germany, and I think it's a thread worth following.

So on that score I look forward to the many collective practices at the seminar, and to the exploratory fields that get generated in that space. Last year on the Saturday we also spent some time in small groups sharing our personal projects involving collectives, and we gave each other feedback and creative input on those, and that'll be good to do again. And I also just really look forward to seeing people whom I met last year, and to meeting some new folks too. One of the great things that emerged out of last years seminar was a whole series of connections and friendships between people, and a lot of that has carried over into Facebook and other online environments this year. And I should add that this is among people of many shapes and ages, and in some cases, culture and color too. It reminds me of what I've been experiencing being in a church congregation. On some level, when you've gathered under some collective intention, everyone's included, everyone's a friend. I do things at the church with eighty year old ladies and in that context, it feels like the most natural thing in the world. Like family. We're in something together, something spanish_revolutionmeaningful, and there's a subtle current of connection that brings the most diverse of people together. It's been an eye opening experience.

And it strikes me that this space of the church, and of the community seminar, can both be seen as versions of a Temporary Autonomous Zone. The TAZ is a concept coined by the anarchist scholar/activist/poet Hakim Bey, and it came to wider prominence this year with the Occupy movement, whose encampments followed this principle. The TAZ, as I understand it, is a space where all of the rules and social relations of the dominant culture get temporarily suspended. It's a free space where humans can explore different ways of being and organizing together, and find out if how they were socialized (or overcoded) is truly the only way to make a world. The Burning Man event in the US was conceived of with the concept of the TAZ in mind, and it's been quite a successful endeavor in that regard. I should point out that the notion of the TAZ is not something Bey invented, but noticed as having (re)occured many times in history. It's apparently some sort of evolutionary strategy for escaping oppressive/stagnant/decaying social systems, and acts as an open space for the exploration and emergence of alternative social realities.

And I see the community seminar as just such an autonomous space, a small pocket of time to experiment with a group of willing others. But the community seminar also has one other aspect worth noting, and that's its explicitly spiritual dimension. I think the recognition of deeper and wider realities within and without, and the cultivation of a recognition of being united beyond self with the All, is also politically important going forward. The political theorist Michael Hardt intuits this same point, and has (very bravely in a postmodern context) brought forth love as a political concept. In their book Multitude, Hardt and his collaborator Antonio Negri write:

People today seem unable to understand love as a political concept, but a concept of love is just what we need to grasp the constituent power of the multitude. The modern concept of love is almost exclusively limited to the bourgeois couple and the claustrophobic confines of the nuclear family. Love has become a strictly private affair. We need a more occupy-lovegenerous and more unrestrained conception of love. We need to recuperate the public and political conception of love common to premodern traditions. Christianity and Judaism, for example, both conceive love as a political act that constructs the multitude. Love means precisely that our expansive encounters and continuous collaborations bring us joy. There is really nothing necessarily metaphysical about the Christian and Judaic love of God: both God's love of humanity and humanity's love of God are expressed and incarnated in the common material political project of the multitude. We need to recover today this material and political sense of love, a love as strong as death. This does not mean you cannot love your spouse, your mother, your child. It only means that your love does not end there, that love serves as the basis for our political projects in common and the construction of a new society. Without this love, we are nothing. (p.351-52)

And from where I stand, the integral community seminar is also an attempt, however frail or feeble, to Occupy Love. And so for all these reasons, I'm stoked about this year's seminar, and I look forward to meeting those who attend. Beams will be also covering the seminar again this year, but we're going to try out a whole new form this time which we're still in the process of conceiving. Something a lot more fun, piecemeal, multimedia and collaborative, so I look forward to what emerges there.

I hope this tiny experiment of the community seminar can contribute to the great passage that's underway across the globe, the movement from the epoch of individualism to the new forms of community and human solidarity that are struggling to emerge in the face of an increasingly globalizing and oppressive Empire. May it be so.



I should also add that what I've written above is only my perspective on the seminar, the way I look at it and come to it. But the diversity of why people come to the seminar and what they're working for in the world, is one very rich part of such a gathering. I want to finish with a video where professor Karen Litfin- who attended last years seminar- talks about her particular focus when it comes to 'evolving the We'. Enjoy.

Related items

Join the Discussion

Commenting Policy

Beams and Struts employs commenting guidelines that we expect all readers to bear in mind when commenting at the site. Please take a moment to read them before posting - Beams and Struts Commenting Policy


  • Comment Link Olen Gunnlaugson Friday, 18 May 2012 22:57 posted by Olen Gunnlaugson

    Br. T,

    Appreciate you taking the time to put this piece together. It really spoke to me. Also really happy you & Juma will be making the journey there.

    Your quote strikes at the center of something really essential in my experience, something we need to bring focus to and amplify at the event--really drive this one home as deeply as we can all go together..

    "We need to recover today this material and political sense of love, a love as strong as death. This does not mean you cannot love your spouse, your mother, your child. It only means that your love does not end there, that love serves as the basis for our political projects in common and the construction of a new society. Without this love, we are nothing. (p.351-52)"

  • Comment Link Trevor Malkinson Saturday, 19 May 2012 21:35 posted by Trevor Malkinson

    Thanks Olen, glad to hear it resonated with you. And I appreciate the intention you're bringing to the seminar. I'm pretty sure there's a big group returning this year, so that should help with the possibilities of going deep and with any luck, opening into some new vistas. lookin forward to it, thanks again for stoppin in and sharing your thoughts.

  • Comment Link Janice Macpherson Sunday, 20 May 2012 06:58 posted by Janice Macpherson

    I appreciated this article so much Trevor because I am hoping to attend this year as well. I am peer-funding as I am well past retirement age and cash poor, but people have been very generous. (See )

    Sydney has a motto "the City of Villages" and I live in the Village of Glebe where the local neighbourhood is very friendly and we share a lot. My grandchildren are home schooled and a local professor of Anatomy at Sydney University gives him lessons at home in science The curator of the Nicholson Museum at the Uni allowed Bill, (7years) to write a story to include in the book being sold at the latest exhibition. My daughter and son-in-law are theatre critics and take neighbours to shows as their "one extra" attendee. The local park is a gathering place for parents and children to catch up and maintain friendships.
    When I first lived in Brisbane, in the mid-70's, we were part of an Intentional community that lived closely together in that city, so it can be done wherever the heart is open to accept the other as part of the "we."

  • Comment Link Amy Jean Cousins Monday, 21 May 2012 01:01 posted by Amy Jean Cousins

    Trevor - this sounds awesome. I look forward to hearing about your journey. I find myself falling in love with people all the time, in the best way - the only thing holding us back from engaging with everyone in this way (I feel) is fear of opening ourselves up to the traps of attachment, sexualization, emotional taxation, etc. How awesome to hold space for LOVE to be the primary currency of exchange, and know we have the capacity to hold it (love) to it's highest form! The more we practice the more it sticks. May it be so.

  • Comment Link Trevor Malkinson Tuesday, 22 May 2012 01:23 posted by Trevor Malkinson

    Janice, nice to hear from you, thanks for the comment. I love that campaign you got going there, that's really cool. I sure hope you hit your mark, but it looks like time is getting tight now (only ten days left to collect the rest)! I'm going to go over and throw down a little contribution myself, I sure hope it works out and we get to see you at the seminar.

    I was really moved by this line of yours yesterday- "It can be done wherever the heart is open to accept the other as part of the "we.""

    There's something deceptively simple and very powerful in that statement. I think it's very true. And now is the time to open up ourselves to the broadest we possible; that's what our global context is calling for and pushing us towards. As serendipity would have it, after reading your passage, I sat down today to watch a new series of videos that Troy Wiley has made. (his first Integral Zeitgeist was great, well timed, and caused some very positive ripples. )

    In the 2nd video of this new series he talks about a new 'neo-tribalism' that's arising beyond what integral would call the yellow meme, or what Troy terms 'integrative consciousness'. This is a new tribalism at a higher level however, one that extends the tribe to the whole globe. That certainly resonates for me, and your phrase struck me as being bang on in conjunction with Troy's videos and what he presents there. Those can be found here:

    Hope to see you in Colorado Janice!

    Amy, glad to hear the piece resonated, particularly the part about love as a political concept/force. I'm glad I listened to myself and tried to pull out this political dimension. I think it's key in ways we don't fully understand yet. Here's a couple of additional points. I mentioned the economic theory/ideology of neoliberalism in the piece (what's also sometimes called free-market fundamentalism, or Reagonomics or Thatherism and is was adopted by those two leaders). The French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu wrote a piece in 1998 that claimed that neoliberalism was "a programme of the methodical destruction of collectives". The destruction of solidarity and all forms of human community have been systematically attacked and eroded under this prevailing ideology, while hyper-individualism has been vigorously promoted (which makes the revival in Ayn Rand's work make perfect sense.

    Here's the Bourdieu piece in full, although it's a typically dense and difficult piece of French postmodern thinking.

    Another passage that caught my eye the other day came via Chris Hedges, in a piece that's actually very interesting its discussion of the erosion of collectives in the modern period. Here's a key summary passage:

    "Rebuilding this older vision of community, one based on cooperation rather than exploitation, will be as important to our survival as changing our patterns of consumption, growing food locally and ending our dependence on fossil fuels".

    The whole article is definitely worth reading.

    So there's a few of other perspectives as to why the move toward collectives and collective action is so important in this period. And few things create connection and a feeling of unity than does opening that heart space and opening into "a love stronger than death", so once again, good on Michael Hardt for opening up that particular discourse.

  • Comment Link Karen Wednesday, 13 June 2012 18:24 posted by Karen

    Wonderful post, Trevor! I've been on the fence about coming to CO but your words are a strong impetus. Echoes of our TAZ on Whidbey last summer still resound in my life - including some Pacific Integral folks who found their way to SkyRoot Commons via that seminar. Check us out:

    So you'll likely see me again in August. And thanks so much for posting the ecovillage video!

  • Comment Link Trevor Malkinson Saturday, 16 June 2012 20:49 posted by Trevor Malkinson

    Karen, thanks for stopping in and for the link to SkyRoot, great to hear from you. I hope to see you at the seminar, and if not I'll have to come to the farm for a visit! hope to catch up sometime either way, cheers, Trevor.

Login to post comments

Search Beams

Most Popular Discussions