“Becoming” a Master or “Being” a Mother: How Do I Choose?

Written by 

The voice over Ikea's loudspeaker announced that we had 15 minutes left to make our final purchases before the store closed. Ryan and I stood together in the midst of bed frames, mattresses, and pillows; the core of domesticity. I hesitated to agree upon on the black frame we both wanted. I was quietly concerned about the noticeably sharp corners.... (would they be hard to childproof?)

Apparently I've gotten to that age (the one I've been warned of for years) where it seems every month another friend or acquaintance announces her pregnancy.

imageedit
Last September on my 28th birthday, Ryan and I were visiting our families in Duluth, Minnesota. That day I prayed to surrender control. Shortly after that I stopped pushing away the truth -- that I was unexplainably drawn to Minnesota, a place I never thought I would return. A place I thought I could never fulfill my potential.

Yet before long, there I was - reconnecting with family and roots, finding community, and falling in love with this imperfect but glorious place that I now call home. Shortly after moving to Minneapolis, I got engaged to Ryan, my soulmate, and we bought a king sized bed.

I halfway tried to conceal the reason I was unsure about the black bed frame with sharp corners. There was something so vulnerable about admitting I even had children on my mind. I'm not sure about being a parent.

Ryan is sure -- always has been. He definitely wants children. He's been talking about it for years. And he'll be an amazing father.

And yes, we're engaged.

And yes, I was well aware of all this when I not-so-subtly suggested that I was ready for Ryan to propose. And so was he.

Some people tell me that I need to get clear on this major issue before we marry. Others tell me I should just go for it and if it turns out we aren't on the same page ... (then they insinuate something along the lines of 'you can always get a divorce'.) Some people just smile and tell me to go ahead, like I have "mommy" stamped in big block letters on my forehead.

None of these answers do it for me.

I didn't decide to get married because I'm in a rush to answer these questions. However, I do recognize they need to be deeply considered.

No, the truth is, I want to marry Ryan because I know profoundly, without a doubt that this relationship is my teacher. That to commit to this sacred container of marriage is to commit to something that I trust I can surrender to, wherever it leads. It allows me to give, to love, receive, and be so much more fully in this life.

You don't show up at your teacher's door and say, "I'll commit only if you tell me where this is definitely headed."

Ryan is amazingly accepting of my uncertainty, yet I want to honor the fact that he is certain. So it seems the most I can do is honestly inquire into the question of mothering.

My own father has been telling me for years that I would be a good parent. He says; "If you'd be good at something and you don't do it, you're depriving the world of your gift."

For many people I know this seems to be at heart of the discussion - is it good for the world? Is it ethical to bring more people into a world of limited resources? Is it selfish not to raise children if you are supposedly smart, loving, and conscious?

We could spend all day in this theoretical debate, but I need to be informed by something that hits closer to home.

frontpage
Like, why, when I received an email from a colleague who is a spiritual practitioner, a writer, is single and traveling the world, in which she opened with "I imagine marriage and babies are just around the corner in your world", I felt an uprising of irritation, even anger churning in my belly?

Was there a problem with her imagining this about me? As though having a home, a husband, and babies were some kind of second rate lifestyle?

It struck a similar chord of irritation that I felt in the Zen center when I heard talk of "lay people;" householders, those with 'regular' jobs, a title I supposed being a mother would immediately qualify me for. My cynical paraphrase goes something like: "For those of you lay people who can't dedicate your life to real spiritual practice as monk, here's a quick meditation you can do to be slightly less of a sleepwalking TOOL."

With great conviction I would think to myself, "I am not a lay person."

So what then? Am I going to be a nun? Yes... I do have a deep calling for what that represents - a life devoted to spiritual practice, and a context that supports it on a day to day basis. Yet I have yet to find any place that resembles what I long for. And the truth is, I deeply enjoy being 'in the world.'

So what was it about the idea of making babies and being a lay person that bothered me?

Was it some doubt about the possibility of combining deep spiritual practice with being a wife, being in the world, and potentially being a mother? I didn't want to believe it, but over the years had received so many messages indicating that I would have to choose between these paths. Though personal experience had already shown me that this is all Mystery, all God, all Consciousness ... I still felt conflicted.

Thus I was extremely grateful when Ryan decided to join me on a week long meditation retreat last spring in Asheville, North Carolina, with a teacher who has had a profound impact on me: Adyashanti. It felt like an opportunity to bring my worlds together--my fiance and I, newly engaged, in silence, with a teacher I deeply respected. I knew that I would be bringing my questions about having children, though I didn't know what that meant.

meditationedit

Bubbly and elated, I dropped into my seat on the train to the Minneapolis airport. I remembered that having a roommate in silence presents it's own strange quirks, so I was excited to tackle this as a team with Ryan before we got to the retreat.

"Let's decide who showers first, so we don't need to communicate at all during the week."

I got the sense that Ryan found this adorably controlling; "I'll just shower when you're not using the bathroom." He smiled and snapped my picture with his phone, set against the skyscrapers behind the train station.

Many hours of travel later, we settled into our small, plain room with two single beds, and said our final I love you's for the week. I wondered if I would be able to set aside the impulse to connect. Being on retreat together without eye contact, touch, or any other communication, highlighted my question - could I be deeply related to someone and also deeply related to silence? I felt driven to know this as I faced the possibility of creating a family.

spirit
In the mornings, the sound of the bell brought me to the large meditation hall, the gravel path wet from the night's spring rain. Flowers burst out everywhere.

I listened to the stillness, to the silence, to the space between. I found myself in presence, and from that place I discovered a nagging voice that was intensely concerned about becoming something. Becoming enlightened, becoming successful, becoming of service to the world, becoming a writer. My ego's loud impulse to matter in some way.

I discovered that this fierce identity of becoming 'something' or 'someone' was even fixated on becoming someone who doesn't care about becoming.

It was an insidious drive thoroughly wrapped up into the idea of enlightenment. A perplexing joke on me.

And then something dropped into my mind about being a mother...it appeared so at odds with all that I wanted to become. Enlightened, successful, a writer, or whatever. I suddenly saw that all my reasons not to have children were wrapped up in what I've been striving to become ... and how I believed being a mother would hold me back.

In a humbling moment all these reasons crumbled, as I saw that all this 'becoming' is simply an ego identity, a form of false control. An illusion.

Being a mother could simply be another way for awareness to come into form. Not a distraction ... rather one of the most challenging and sacred forms of spiritual practice I could imagine or engage.

With this shift, I became more available to honestly face the real question - is mothering the form of love that Life is asking of me? Is this how I am called to bring love into this world?

And the truth is - I don't know. This is not yet clear to me. Clearly I am not in control of Life, though I am a deeply engaged participant. I might not know for years.

All I can do is listen.

nativespirit

--

Editors: Emelia Symington Fedy, TJ Dawe, Chela Davison

Related items

Join the Discussion

Commenting Policy

Beams and Struts employs commenting guidelines that we expect all readers to bear in mind when commenting at the site. Please take a moment to read them before posting - Beams and Struts Commenting Policy

13 comments

  • Comment Link Korenna Wednesday, 10 October 2012 18:29 posted by Korenna

    I love you for sharing this. I threw myself into my career after Kayla died, and wasn't sure I'd ever choose parenthood again. And then, parenthood chose me. And I strive to manage both my career & my role as Mom, and every second of every day I strive to recognize that EACH provide me with ample opportunity for growth, for contribution, For spiritual practice. And, that all I can really do is surrender and be present.

  • Comment Link San from Amsterdam Wednesday, 10 October 2012 18:53 posted by San from Amsterdam

    Thank you for sharing your thoughts and feelings! I am a mother of two beautifull kids, and I am also a spiritually aware and involved woman with goals and dreams and ambitions. And I really like the way you said that these are actually all ego things. They are also based in the future, in which you can't actually see all the other facets that will occur at that moment, in the future. So you don't really know, right. What you have is this moment, and this moment will tell you the answer. If you feel and listen, like you so beautifully said. I will share with you my ideas about what it's like being a parent on a more spiritual level. It is a very humbling and very deep experience, in which you get connected to a form of love unknown and inimaginable untill you experience it. It is tough too though, it is the best challenge to stay in the now, and to stay calm, and to stay connected to yourself (if you really want to be there for your kids and not dreaming away while they want to read a book with you). I believe being a parent is the most important job in the world, but also the best spiritual experience in the world. From the source of love and life comes a spirit to be with you and to be tought, loved and guided by you. And it works the other way around as well, this spirit is there to guide, love and teach you. There is just so much beauty in this!! It is definitly the most underestemated "job" in the world. Whatever life has in store for you, open your hands, open your heart and welcome it with all the love you can pass through it. And also, on a more practical note, being a writer is THE perfect job to combine with parenting. And, two children leaves no more people on this planet after you and your partner pass away....:-)

  • Comment Link Marco V Morelli Wednesday, 10 October 2012 19:18 posted by Marco V Morelli

    Someone once described parenting as "all joy and no fun." Sounds like a spiritual path to me ;)

    But on the question of writing and meditation, if you do become a mom one day, I would suggest making sure to set up your own quiet, secluded, sacred personal space somewhere in the house. Simply having a "room of your own" can make all the difference when it comes to differentiating/integrating your many selves and aspirations.

  • Comment Link Emily Levang Wednesday, 10 October 2012 22:10 posted by Emily Levang

    Hi Korenna,

    Thank you! I love hearing this from you... your Facebook updates on mothering have been providing me with a steady stream of inspiration about the possibility of mothering with humor and surrender and simple fact of the matter this-is-life-ness. It's really helpful for me to see real examples of this!

    And I am still eagerly awaiting the day I get to meet Raine! Much love to you.

    Emily

  • Comment Link Emily Levang Wednesday, 10 October 2012 22:32 posted by Emily Levang

    Hi San,

    What you shared really touches me. You've hit on so much of what I suppose I am longing to hear, from experienced parents. Part of me of course intuits all this, and yet as you said, the mind can make up all sorts of things that are based in the future. Even this experience as you say, of "love unknown and inimaginable until you experience it" can be bring up fear ... That depth of love is so vulnerable! Even as I read your words there is a part of me that is afraid to love so deeply. AND - it is only by being with this fear that I can feel also the intense heart breaking beauty of that love, which is not something I am here on earth to shy away from. Thank you so much for helping me to feel this!

    On a practical level, your points are exactly what I need to hear. I've been noticing lately that committing more deeply to writing makes it much easier to conceive of being a mother.

    I have a question for you (and also for Korenna and Marco and anyone else ) - have you had community support in raising children spiritually? This feels so important to me and just hearing from you three here has already made me feel much more connected to that possibility.

    Thank you so much for sharing San!

    Blessings,
    Emily

  • Comment Link Emily Levang Wednesday, 10 October 2012 22:48 posted by Emily Levang

    Marco,

    "All joy and no fun," does sound like a spiritual path! :-)

    Thanks for that practical tip - I can imagine that it is SO important in so many ways to have this space.

    Love,
    Emily

  • Comment Link Kathryn Ehnebuske Thursday, 11 October 2012 02:29 posted by Kathryn Ehnebuske

    Emily

    My partner and I read your article and were profoundly touched and encouraged by your conscious and wise approach to considering parenting. We made just that choice, to honor love, to surrender to the service asked of a parent, especially when there is also a commitment to spiritual growth. Our children are 33 and 30 and have never ceased to be our greatest teachers, a monastery par excellence where you are held to the path by the power to love more than you thought you ever could.

  • Comment Link Kate Thursday, 11 October 2012 11:22 posted by Kate

    I love what you have written! I am a mama, and so far, parenthood has been the most intense spiritual journey ever. Nothing has ever challenged or stretched me as much. When it gets really hard, and I feel I am at my limit, I have an image in my head of motherhood as being like heading up to the mountains to my spiritual guru...I am stripped of everything I own and everything I 'know'. Every mollecule of me and what I believe about myself is challenged. Motherhood is teaching me that I don't truly know my own limits, that i can be stretched beyond imagining, that I have love and patience even in the darkest places. It is teaching me to be flexible with time, that life and death exist so closely together and to make the most of every moment regardless of what may be about to happen. It's making a warrior out of me, it's humbling me, it shoves my greatest fears in my face every night as I listen in the dark to make sure my baby is still breathing. It humbles me and shows me my own face in the mirror when I judge other parents. Pregnancy, birth and breastfeeding were sensual, gritty and earthy. I am more sensual and in awe of my body, with it's stretch marks and saggier boobs now...I have a kind of reverence for it. I feel angry when motherhood is reduced to something flimsy and non-valuable by our society. It is every mother climbing her own Everest! All the best with your own journey, however it unfolds! :)

  • Comment Link Carmien Friday, 12 October 2012 12:02 posted by Carmien

    Beloved, thank you for sharing.

    What comes to mind, what my heart bids me share is this - as an individual we can awaken to Truth and light the world around us. As a parent we can raise a child as we awaken, and so inspire them to awaken to Truth. Parenting offers us the gift of reflection. And each child raised in love and Truth will be one more light living in this world.

    I say this as a father of a 5 year old and a student and practitioner of Truth. My daughter has taught me through her very presence. She has reflected Truth, been Truth and forgotten Truth. She sometimes meditates with me. She sometimes lives in thoroughly in the world of "self".

    You have asked the question and Truth will surely be revealed.

    Know the Flow and be happy.

  • Comment Link Marie Friday, 12 October 2012 12:58 posted by Marie

    Dear Emily, thank you so much for writing about this one!

    I have been going through very similar questions myself, and I find that the topic isn't so well covered or even included and honored as part of the spiritual journey, in our world of truth seekers/coaches/etc...It's as if achievement and success remain closely associated with career, very simply put..., and no matter how evolved and second-tier we pride ourselves to be. We become condescendant. I certainly have been, towards my friends who made the choice of motherhood earlier on.

    I've considered becoming a mother would be putting a break to my "Evolution". And now I know that of course it won't be - AND that, of course, it will be - if only because, practically speaking, I know my man will continue to go to work every day because that's what he wants to do - and I'm the free-lancer who will be flexible - and happy to be, actually.

    I know that it will be chaos even though I don't know what chaos is really like. I've once read the Dynamic Feminine is like a Tsunami. That's what I'm expecting becoming a mother will be, and that's precisely why I've resisted it for so long....And I've now realised that what I most long for, isn't a more successful, better, bigger career, before I...; it is to surrender to Life and to Love. So now, I'm inviting it. It's both scary and feels so right.

    And I hope you will be writing some more!

  • Comment Link Elyse Saturday, 13 October 2012 01:58 posted by Elyse

    Emily,

    This article speaks so directly to me, I'll be referring back to it often as I continue my own adventure with love and freedom. ;)

    Thank you for voicing this to generations of women who have chosen paths and for women who have yet to choose.

    Please keep us posted on your journey!

  • Comment Link Emily Levang Saturday, 13 October 2012 02:55 posted by Emily Levang

    Kate,

    I hear your warrior cry. I hear your naked heart. I hear that I too, long for this depth of love, this plunge into life and death. What you have given voice to is, underneath it all, what I most deeply yearn for. Some part of me is laughing at this other part of me that thought maybe I would find it in some easier way.

    Thank you expressing this so beautifully.

    Love,
    Emily

  • Comment Link Emily Levang Saturday, 13 October 2012 04:52 posted by Emily Levang

    Hi Marie,

    Yes I'm with you ... my longing is also, as you said "to surrender to Life and to Love" it is both scary and right.

    I like how you said you are now inviting it... I resonante with that too. It feels so different to be genuinely inviting.

    I'm really glad you brought up how this isn't very well covered as part of the spiritual journey, and how this seems to lead to condescending attitudes. I've noticed that too, in myself and others. Right now as I see that, it strikes me as incredibly sad.

    I honestly can't tell if I haven't seen motherhood honored in the spiritual path because I haven't been looking for it/open to it, or if it's really not very present. Probably both. I feel interested now in finding more resources.

    Thank you again for bringing these things up!

    Warmly,
    Emily

Login to post comments

Search Beams

Most Popular Discussions